New Hire Training Evaluation Form

What this evaluation is for

A new hire training evaluation is a systematic way to document how a new employee is performing against predefined metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs) during their training period. Rather than relying on memory or informal impressions, the evaluation captures what was observed, whether the new hire met expectations, and what recommendations follow. This form is designed for trainers and others responsible for onboarding new employees. It has three sections — **Audit**, **General Evaluation**, and **Metric** — covering 11 prompts in total.

What a good evaluation covers

A complete evaluation starts with the **Audit** section, where you record the date conducted, who prepared the evaluation, and the location. This gives each evaluation a clear author, time, and place, which matters when you review progress across a training period. The **General Evaluation** section carries the instructions for the process, the signatures, the finish time, and the real start and end dates for the inspection. Signatures confirm that both the evaluator and the new hire have reviewed the assessment, and the start and end dates let you tie the evaluation to a specific window of training. The **Metric** section is where the substance sits. For each training metric or KPI you assess, you specify the metric, answer whether the new hire met the expectation using a Yes / No / N/A scale, and provide detailed observations and recommendations. The N/A option is there for metrics that genuinely do not apply to the role or the stage of training.

How to carry out the evaluation

Work through the form during the new hire's training period, not as a single end-of-training exercise. 1. Complete the **Audit** section first: date conducted, prepared by, and location. 2. Read the **Instructions** in the **General Evaluation** section before you begin observing. 3. Move to the **Metric** section and specify the training metric or KPI you are assessing. 4. Assess whether the new hire met expectations for that metric — Yes, No, or N/A. 5. Write detailed observations and recommendations for that metric, with concrete examples rather than general impressions. 6. Repeat steps 3 to 5 for each metric or KPI you are tracking. 7. Close the evaluation by collecting signatures and recording the finish time, real start date, and real end date.

Why it matters

Documenting performance against defined metrics and KPIs turns training feedback into something you can act on and revisit. Recommendations captured alongside observations give you a practical basis for coaching and for deciding where additional support is needed. Because each evaluation records the author, the location, and the dates, you can also monitor an employee's development over the course of the training period rather than judging it from a single point in time.

Frequently Asked Questions

A new hire training evaluation is a structured way to observe and document how a new employee is progressing during their training period. You record who conducted the evaluation, where it took place, and when, then assess the new hire against defined metrics or key performance indicators (KPIs). For each metric you note whether the new hire met expectations and provide detailed observations and recommendations. Both the trainee and the evaluator sign off, and the real start and end dates of the evaluation period are recorded.

It gives trainers and hiring managers an objective, consistent record of how a new employee is performing against agreed metrics and KPIs. This makes it easier to provide actionable feedback during the training period, to spot where extra support is needed, and to track progress over time. It also creates a documented basis for the signature sign-off by the evaluator and new hire.

A complete evaluation records the date it was conducted, who prepared it, and the location. You then specify each training metric or KPI being assessed, note whether the new hire met expectations (Yes, No, or N/A), and write detailed observations and recommendations for that metric. The form closes with signatures and the real start and end dates of the evaluation period.

Work through the form during the new hire's training period. Begin with the audit section: record the date conducted, who prepared the evaluation, and the location. In the general evaluation section, follow the instructions provided on the form, capture signatures, and log the finish time along with the real start and end dates of the inspection period. In the metric section, specify the training metric or KPI you are assessing, indicate whether the new hire met expectations using the Yes / No / N/A scale, then write detailed observations and recommendations. Repeat the metric assessment for each KPI you are tracking, then review the completed form with the new hire.

Written by

Arne Reis

Founder

Process optimizer with 25 years of expertise, focused on operational excellence in quality, maintenance, EHS, and commissioning. Emphasizes innovative solutions and top-quality standards.

View LinkedIn profile